does your baby need milk?

Jessica Penner, RDUncategorized4 Comments

Does my baby need milk?

This is one of the top questions I get asked from parents. The short answer is, yes, your baby does need milk! But the long answer is still needed because the type of milk is key, depending on the baby’s age.

Historically, this question would not have popped into anyone’s minds. It wasn’t until recently that breastfeeding into toddlerhood was the norm. In today’s North American culture, most mothers wean before one year. In fact, breastfeeding longer than 12 months is considered “extended breastfeeding”

Terms such as that certainly don’t help to normalize breastfeeding! But I digress…

Your baby needs milk. The combination of a fast growth rate and a small stomach means that the majority of food and beverage to enter her mouth needs to contribute to her growth.

Nutritionally, milk provides the following:

  • fat and calories
  • minerals
  • vitamins
  • some protein

one milk at a time

As long as you’re breastfeeding your baby, you don’t need to offer him other milk. If you are formula feeding your baby, you don’t need to add in cow’s milk. Once the baby is old enough, however, you can switch over to cow’s milk.

0-6 months: Only breastmilk or formula needed

6-9 months: Breastmilk or formula plus appropriate complementary foods

9-12 months: Whole cow’s milk can be subbed for breastmilk or formula ONLY if baby is eating high iron foods at least 2 x/day regularly

12 months +: Whole cow’s milk can be subbed for either breastmilk or formula

24 months +: 2% milk or dairy alternatives (ex: soy beverage, goat’s milk) can be subbed for whole cow’s milk

the logic

Let’s take a look at why this progression is recommended. 

 Breast

milk

Whole cow’s milk2% cow’s milkSoy beverageAlmond beverageWhole Goat’s milk (enriched)Rice milkCoconut beverage
Calories182 kcal157 kcal129 kcal110 kcal60 kcal178 kcal127 kcal 45 kcal
Fat (g)11.88.15.13.82.510.72.1 4.5
Protein (g)2.78.48.56.719.80.4 0.5
Carbs (g)17.912.412.412.6711.526.3 2
Calcium 83291309321~300345319 0
Magnesium82628396%3610 ?
Iron0.080.080.051.084%0.130.21 2%
Folate13 DFE13 DFE13 DFE23 37 DFE (3 naturally occurring)96 DFE ?
Sodium44111121121 12991 15
SourceCNFDCNFDCNFDCNFDalmond breeeze.caCNFDCNFD so delicious

milk comparison: 1 cup (250 ml)

The differences between these types of milk may seem small and insignificant. But the human infant was designed to grow optimally on breastmilk. So it’s very important to transition slowly from a primarily breastmilk (or breastmilk replicate) based diet to a primarily solid food-based diet. Some people don’t realize the significant contribution milk makes to the caloric intake of a child. At 12 months, a child gets approximately 35-40% of their calories from “milk”. It is recommended that a child over 12 months drink between 2-3 cups of milk. This would be 314-461 kcal.

Additionally, blood values of nutrients are tightly regulated. Sodium is mainly regulated by the kidneys. In adults, if there is an excess amount of sodium, the kidneys will filter it out into the urine. If there is not an excess, the kidneys will reabsorb the sodium back into the blood. Sodium levels in breastmilk are relatively low. As such, the human infant’s kidneys are automatically programmed to refilter sodium back into the blood. The regulatory mechanisms slowly mature with age.

 

why not _ milk?

There are several milk alternatives on the market. None of them are appropriate for children under two years of age. If a child is no longer breastfeeding and is unable to drink whole cow’s milk, formula should be given.

  • Goat’s milk is naturally low in folate. If goat’s milk is offered to children it should be whole fat goat’s milk fortified with folic acid (synthetic folate). 
  • Soy beverage is low in fat and slightly low in protein.
  • Rice, almond, coconut, and hemp beverages are low in protein, fat, and calories.  

whole milk? ….really?

In the 70s, childhood obesity was on the rise. With good intentions to reduce this trend, some physicians started to recommend that infants be given skim (fat-free) milk. This study shows babies fed skim milk deplete their fat stores to maintain growth in length. Children need the fat for brain development and the additional calories fat provides for growth. 

milk limit

Did you catch the recommended range for milk intake in children I listed above? For the most part, I advocate for a feeding relationship with children that follows Ellyn Satter’s division of responsibility in which the caregivers determine what food is offered, when and where. While the child determines whether they’ll eat and, if so, how much of which foods offered. In this relationship, the caregivers don’t set a minimum or maximum amount of food. Milk, however, can be the exception. I don’t recommend forcing a child who doesn’t like milk to drink it. For those children, you’ll need to be more creative in offering dairy or alternatives in a way they’ll accept (example: cook oatmeal in milk instead of water). On the opposite side, there are children who will happily consume milk all day long to the detriment of other foods. Those children need a milk restriction. Too much of a good thing does exist! Children who drink more than 3 cups (750 ml or 24 oz) of milk a day are at higher risk of developing an iron deficiency. This is because:

  • milk is a low source of iron
  • calcium in milk can inhibit iron absorption
  • high milk intake can lower intakes of other foods (some of which will be the high iron sources or sources of Vitamin C, which helps increase iron absorption)

 

Subscribe for exclusive access to my meal planning hacks ebook!
Smart Nutrition Logo Arrow subscribe

4 Comments on “does your baby need milk?”

  1. Hello! My baby is 5 months old and I am reading up so I will be ready to start introducing solid foods when she is 6 months old. She is formula fed, and right now is on a “stage 1” formula for birth to 6 months of age, then I am supposed to switch her to the follow up 6 to 12 months formula. My question is if I need to make that switch gradually or not? Also, should I make the switch before starting the solid food? if I make the switch before starting solid food do I have to offer her water in a cup before starting the solid food? I haven´t been able to find an answer to these questions, and I really want to make sure that I get it right. Her formula is iron and vitamin D fortified. I appreciate your help, thank you.

    1. Stage 2 formulas are simply marketing. Babies can either stay on stage 1 or be offered stage 2. Both are appropriate from age 6-12 months. As a general recommendation the main thing is to make sure the formula is iron fortified!

  2. My husband and I drink Ripple, which is a plant based (pea protein) milk substitute. Once our son is 24 months is that something he can consume instead of cow’s milk?

    1. Check the fortification for Vitamin D! In Canada Rippl doesn’t have Vitamin D added to it yet. But yes, otherwise it’s a suitable option once your son is 24 months.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *